Sacred Texts
Yoga Vāsiṣṭha cover

॥ श्री ॥vedantaFor reading

Yoga Vāsiṣṭha 2.18.56

Traditional (ascribed to Vālmīki)

Prakaraṇas
6
Sargas
175
Published
73
Verses
2878
Level
intermediate

Sarga 18 · Verse 56

Verse 56

एवं सति निराकारे ब्रह्मण्याकारवान् कथम् । दृष्टान्त इति नोद्यन्ति मूर्खवैकल्पिकोक्तयः ॥ ५६ ॥

ēvaṁ sati nirākārē brahmaṇyākāravān katham | dṛṣṭānta iti nōdyanti mūrkhavaikalpikōktayaḥ || 56 ||

Translation

This being so, the fools' quibbles, 'How can there be an illustration with form for Brahman without form?', do not arise.

Word by word

ēvaṁ
this
sati
being so
nirākārē
without form
brahmaṇi
for Brahman
ākāravān
with form
katham
how
dṛṣṭānta
(dṛṣṭāntaḥ) an illustration
iti
thus
na
not
udyanti
arise
mūrkha
of fools
vaikalpika
the quibbling
uktayaḥ
words

Meaning

The commentary names the quibbles: is Brahman with a second or without? If with, the doctrine is lost; if without, teacher and scripture are gone and knowledge cannot arise. Once it is clear that illustrations work only in part and belong to the world of appearance, such objections have no ground to stand on.