Sacred Texts
Yoga Vāsiṣṭha cover

॥ श्री ॥vedantaFor reading

Yoga Vāsiṣṭha 2.8.10

Traditional (ascribed to Vālmīki)

Prakaraṇas
6
Sargas
175
Published
88
Verses
3571
Level
intermediate

Sarga 8 · Verse 10

Verse 10

मिथोऽङ्गानि समासाद्य द्वयोरेकैककर्तृता । हस्तादीनां हतत्वे ह न दैवेन क्वचित्कृतम् ॥ १० ॥

mithō’ṅgāni samāsādya dvayōrēkaikakartṛtā | hastādīnāṁ hatatvē ha na daivēna kvacitkṛtam || 10 ||

Translation

When two things meet, limb and tool, the work is the work of one or the other. When hands and the like have been destroyed, nothing has ever been done by fate.

Word by word

mithō
(mithaḥ) together
aṅgāni
limbs
samāsādya
meeting
dvayōr
(dvayoḥ) of two
ēkaika
one or the other
kartṛtā
the work
hasta
hands
ādīnāṁ
and the like
hatatvē
when destroyed
ha
indeed
na
not
daivēna
by fate
kvacit
ever
kṛtam
done

Meaning

The commentary gives the examples: in writing and cutting, pen or razor and hand meet, and of the two only one does the work; another commentary adds that when the hand has been struck with palsy, fate has never yet moved the pen. So tools and limbs are in the visible chain of causes, and fate is nowhere in it. The test is what happens when the hand is gone. If fate were really a doer, its work would go on. It stops. It can be hard to read this and not think of one's own limbs: these hands are what is available to the good one means to do, and for a limited time.