Sacred Texts
Mahānirvāṇa Tantra cover

॥ श्री ॥tantraFor reading

Mahānirvāṇa Tantra 11.80

Traditional

Ullāsas
14
Verses
2517
Minutes
1258
Level
advanced

Ullāsa 11 · Verse 80

नरघातकपापनिरूपणम्Who bears the sin of a killing

Verse 80

यो हन्यान्मानवं भर्त्तुराज्ञयापरिहार्यया । भर्त्तुरेव वधस्तत्र प्रहर्त्तुर्न शिवाज्ञया ॥ ८० ॥

yō hanyānmānavaṁ bhartturājñayāparihāryayā | bhartturēva vadhastatra prahartturna śivājñayā || 80 ||

Translation

When one kills a man by his master's command that cannot be refused, by Śiva's command the death penalty falls on the master, not on the striker.

Word by word

yaḥ
(yaḥ) who
hanyāt
(hanyāt) kills
mānavaṁ
a man
bharttuḥ
(bhartuḥ) of the master
ājñayā
by command
aparihāryayā
that cannot be refused
ēva
alone
vadhaḥ
(vadhaḥ) death
tatra
there
praharttuḥ
(prahartuḥ) of the striker
na
not
śiva
Śiva's

Meaning

Responsibility lies with the one who orders, if the servant cannot refuse.

Commentary

Hariharānanda Bhāratī’s Sanskrit commentary, translated

Now he says that when a servant who cannot disobey his master's command kills a man, death is to be imposed on the master alone, not on the servant, with "yaḥ" and the rest. One who kills a man by the master's command that cannot be avoided, that cannot be transgressed: in that killing there is no death for the striker, but by Śiva's command death is laid down for the master alone. "That cannot be avoided" suggests that if a servant able to transgress the master's command kills a man, then death is his own.